Andrew Cartmel

Reviewed on 6th September 2025

Another adventure for the Vinyl Detective and friends starts, unusually, with some visitors asking him not to take a case. This is the sort of casual twist that makes for a really enjoyable and entertaining crime comedy series.

I enjoyed catching up with these characters, although I do think in places the reliance of returning characters from earlier novels is stretchingthe abilities of my memory now.

I don't know what more there is to say but that it's a good, fun, entertaining read.

read more

Reviewed on 29th March 2025

Cordelia is back, and hired to find out who stole some books from the local yoga centre.

I'm absolutely hooked on Cartmel's novels and am worried that I've nearly caught up. His narrative is so welcoming and really aligns with the character in a way that feels like you're really seeing things through her mind. Cordelia is a great character, somehow both larger than life and totally believable at the same time.

The plot is great - it's silly and funny and yet also not entirely implausible. It holds up as a mystery, and a thriller, while remaining light and easy holiday reading.

I can't wait for more Cordelia stories and to see how this world will develop further in books to come.

read more

Reviewed on 2nd November 2024

I just find that I really enjoy hanging out with these characters that Cartmel has invented. Yes they go and have adventures finding records and murderers, but they seem to just have a good life between that too, with a good bunch of friends.

As always, it’s a really easy read, and I find that makes it flow past really quickly. The plot is good fun, introducing some new characters, while revisiting others to help things along and give little references for the long-term reader.

A great way to relax and have fun without having to think too much.

read more

Reviewed on 29th June 2024

After reading a hefty non-fiction tome and trying to read something which turned out to be very much not my thing, I turned to Andrew Cartmel, whose previous novels I’ve found very relaxing and enjoyable.

The Paperback Sleuth is the opening to a new series with a new main character, but very quickly becomes clear that it’s the same world as the Vinyl Detective series, and Cartmel makes great ongoing jokes out of cross-over between the two.

This though has a new tone. Cordelia, our main character, has a more chilled attitude to life, and that’s reflected in slightly more graphic sex and drugs references than those in the previous series.

It’s a really good book, and I absolutely stormed through it in two days, aided by the weather being perfectly attuned for sitting out in the garden in the evenings.

read more

Reviewed on 7th April 2024

Book six sees the Vinyl Detective and ever expanding posse head to Sweden on the trail of a rare special edition album which has totally nothing dangerous about it whatsoever.

It’s a great detective novel, with a bunch of really compelling characters who are essentially going on holiday together and having a laugh.

I don’t feel that the humour is as strong in the earliest novel, but that’s doesn’t get in the way of adding some. One new character in particular feels like she brings a remarkable joke that someone is endearing despite it keep giving more and more material for the book to work with.

I find these novels very comforting to read and am happy to see that Cartmel has another series now started that I can catch up with too.

read more

Reviewed on 17th September 2023

The fifth Vinyl Detective novel feels back on form after I found the previous one a little lacking.

I’m not convinced that the humour in the narrative is up to the levels of the earliest novels though, which my memory tells me had me laughing much more.

Instead it’s a light but dangerous plot, as the quite highly expanded cast of regular characters gets together again to try to find a) who is trying to kill one of them, and b) a valuable record.

I raced through this one and enjoyed it all round. Looking forward to more.

read more

Reviewed on 3rd April 2023

The fourth adventure for the Vinyl Detective sees him trying to track down a rare record for a friend, and visiting the quite wacky band who produced it.

I found that this entry lacked something that I’ve come to expect from the series. The humour felt muted and less laugh-out-loud, and the peril almost felt more real and therefore less escapist.

The plot is outlandish, but I’m not sure it’s not too far, and seems to be a lot driving on coincidence rather than events that are caused by events. I’m still not entirely sure why many of the things in the plot even happened.

read more