21st February 2026
It's taken me months and months to get through this book, despite the hype, and despite having bought one of the special editions. I have two contrasting views - one on the story, and one on the reading experience.
The story is great. It's a massively extended version of a short that I'd read before, and explores the Cosmere far into the timeline. As such, there's a lot of references to other worlds previously and not-yet explored, which is both great, but also a bit weird because I feel like I'd have prefered to watch those worlds grow more chronologically to understand them better.
The main characters are really interesting - a solid contrast between Sixth, a trapper, exploring a new place for the first time and seeing things with new eyes, bringing us along for the ride, and Starling, a dragon, trying to look after her really diverse crewmates despite having lost most of her abilities.
The problem I think I had the most though was the form of the special edition - and this is potentially a small silly spoiler if this is the version you've got and not read yet. There's a very clever artistic twist, where after starting out like a normal book, something in the plot triggers the pages to invert, and then for most of the book it's printed in silver ink on black paper. While this looks great at first, it quickly became a nuisance to actually read - the light has to hit the pages at exactly the right angle for the ink to be visible. I think that's the main reason it took me so many months to get to, just the awkwardness of holding such a big, heavy tome at the perfect angle for each page.
So, recommended in the regular edition (assuming it doesn't have the gimmick) for the story.
read more