The Secret of the Old Mill by Franklin W Dixon - Shastrix Books

The Secret of the Old Mill
Filled StarFilled StarFilled StarEmpty StarEmpty Star

The Secret of the Old Mill

Franklin W Dixon, Leslie McFarlane & Alistair Hunter

ISBN: 0448089033

Description

The Hardy boys learn a case of counterfeit money is somehow intertwined with a national security case their dad is working on.

Reviewed on 28th September 2014

My copy of this, the third book in the original Hardy Boys series, is the updated (1962) and Britishified edition. The first two books I re-read recently both have a feeling of being the start of the series, but for the most part this one seems like it's written to be just a regular episode - although later on there are some new recurring elements introduced.

The plot this time feels patchy, and doesn't quite hold together properly - the Hardys are drawn into a hunt for some counterfeiters, but the line between their case and their father's becomes sketchy, and its not really clear through much of the story what is actually being investigated. What I can only assume is the 'update' introduces the idea of 'secret space missiles' which feel out of place and not very secret as everyone in the town knows about them.

The side characters again feel like they have more definition here than the stars - we know the Hardys' friend Chet Morton better than any other character by this point in the series whereas the Hardy Boys themselves still seem to have little to distinguish them from each other. This doesn't quite tally with some of my memories of reading the books twenty years ago when I recall one being more reserved and one more impulsive. Another aspect I hadn't remembered was the characters' reliance on motorbikes at this point in their history.

I think this is probably the weakest of the first three stories - the plot is unclear and the investigation seems to follow the right path without any real planning going into it. There are times when coincidence pushes the story too much and there's never a real sense of peril as there certainly was in the previous book.

More books

  1. Filled StarFilled StarFilled StarFilled StarEmpty Star
  2. The Mystery of Cabin Island
  3. Filled StarFilled StarFilled StarFilled StarEmpty Star
  4. What Happened At Midnight
  5. Filled StarFilled StarFilled StarFilled StarEmpty Star
  6. The House on the Cliff
  7. Filled StarFilled StarFilled StarFilled StarEmpty Star
  8. While the Clock Ticked
  9. Filled StarFilled StarFilled StarFilled StarEmpty Star
  10. The Shore Road Mystery
  11. Filled StarFilled StarFilled StarFilled StarEmpty Star
  12. The Twisted Claw
  13. Filled StarFilled StarFilled StarFilled StarEmpty Star
  14. The Secret Warning